Mushroom popcorn kernels are one of the most unique and sought-after varieties as they produce the crispiest, tastiest end product every time. For this reason, many brands have started offering their own take on them, which has made finding the ideal product more difficult than ever.

The best mushroom popcorn kernels should be free from additives and create a firm popped shape with a delicious chewiness. Brands such as Amish County and Gold Medal make stellar mushroom popcorn while Hi-Pop, TableTop King and the Wabash Valley Farm mushroom corn are also great options. 

Mushroom popcorn isn’t as flimsy and frail as traditional butterfly popcorn and its gently rounded shape makes it great for soaking up butter and seasoning. In this article, I’ll take you through the qualities that set each of these alternatives apart to help you decide on the product that fits your needs and budget best.

What Are The Best-Selling Mushroom Popcorn Kernels?

Currently, the best-selling mushroom popcorn kernels are the Amish Country Popcorn Kernels. Their popularity comes as a result of their affordable price point, high-quality corn, which is gluten and GMO free. 

There’s a reason why so many customers seem to rave about the Amish Country Popcorn (available on, as the brand has been able to deliver excellent taste and shape for one of the best prices in today’s market.

Their popcorn kernels are also gluten-free and non-GMO, allowing all family members to eat them with peace of mind. Additionally, the variety is very low calorie while still maintaining its buttery taste, making it ideal for those looking to lose a few extra pounds.

Amish Country mushroom popcorn kernels are also tree nut and peanut-free, meaning that you won’t have to worry about any hidden allergens that might render the product inedible. 

With so many brands adding a wide range of additives and flavorings to their kernels, it’s hard to find a product that you can eat out of the bag without worrying about the ingredient list. As far as allergies go, Amish Country has got you covered.

One of the most innovative perks the company offers with its product is a recipe guide eBook to help you find the tastiest ways to prepare your popcorn without having to search for any lengthy or hard-to-follow recipes.

Overall, I highly recommend giving Amish Country a try, as they offer excellent value for the price through their delicious, sizey, allergen-free mushroom popcorn kernels.

What Are The Best Mushroom Popcorn Kernels To Buy In Bulk?

The best mushroom popcorn kernels to buy in bulk are the Gold Medal Mushroom Popcorn Kernels. They offer some of the most sizable options on the market today without sacrificing taste or quality.

The Gold Medal Mushroom Popcorn Kernels (available on come in an impressive 50-pound (22.68 kg) bag, which brings them to a price point at an affordable price per ounce (28.35 g). For this reason, the Gold Medal popcorn kernels are ideal for those looking to operate a popcorn machine both in a commercial or domestic setting.

The brand’s product makes great-sized popcorn, but it often produces a bit of shell flaking, so keep that in mind if it’s a dealbreaker for you. Apart from this, there’s not much else to complain about when it comes to the Gold Medal kernels, as their end-product consistently comes out flawless.

Therefore, for those who eat mushroom popcorn frequently or want to use it commercially, there’s no better brand to buy in bulk than Gold Medal.

They also make an excellent base for sugar popcorn. I would suggest using ½ cup (64 g) sugar, ½ cup (64 g) popping oil, and ¾ cup (96 g) Gold Medal popcorn kernels for the tastiest sweet-but-not-to-sweet, crunchiest popcorn you’ll ever have.

What Brand Of Mushroom Popcorn Kernels Offers The Best Value?

The brand of mushroom popcorn kernels that offers the best value is Hi-Pop. They provide the most affordable alternative on the market while still delivering excellent taste and high-quality ingredients.

You likely won’t find a better deal on the market than Reist Popcorn Company Hi-Pop Popcorn (available on Not only is their popcorn affordable, but its taste can compete even with some of the higher-end alternatives on this list.

Furthermore, they offer some of the healthiest mushroom popcorn kernels, as theirs are non-GMO and packed with whole grain fiber and protein. Additionally, all of the brand’s products are grown and processed in the USA, which means they’ve gone through the strictest quality control and production practices policies.

Therefore, for those looking for a sizable bag of mushroom popcorn kernels as affordable as it’s high-quality, you won’t find a better value than what Hi-Pop offers.

What Are The Best Extra Large Mushroom Popcorn Kernels?

The best extra large mushroom popcorn kernels are the TableTop King Mushroom Popcorn Kernels. After popping, they make for some of the biggest, crispiest popcorn that has the surface area to make your flavors intensified. 

Sometimes, normal-sized popcorn just isn’t satisfying enough, which will leave you looking for the best kernels to produce a bigger, more filling end product. This is where the TableTop King Mushroom Popcorn Kernels (available on are unbeatable.

Their extra-large size doesn’t affect their taste, as the caramel flavor still shines through even the biggest pieces of popcorn, leaving a sweet, aromatic aftertaste.

This TableTop King product is much less prone to crushing compared to other brands, and their ridged surface makes them an excellent base for any saucy toppings you’d like to add. 

Given that these kernels were designed to be paired with a variety of sauces and creams, they also have the ability to maintain their freshness and crispiness for hours without becoming soggy or stale.

Overall, for those looking for that extra-large look and feel in their popcorn, you won’t find a better alternative than TableTop King.

What Are the Highest Quality Mushroom Popcorn Kernels?

The highest-quality mushroom popcorn kernels are the Wabash Valley Farms Popcorn Kernels. The brand offers a gourmet product that’ll deliver the most flavorful and natural taste and their oversize shape makes them the best for toppings. 

We’ve now entered the highest end of the price range. The Wabash Valley Farms Popcorn Kernels (available on produce a gourmet, naturally-flavored product ideal for those willing to invest a bit more to get the best there is. Their popcorn is ideal for those with an acquired taste or those looking to find the perfect gift to give to their popcorn-loving friend.

Their delicious caramel flavor and scent can be combined with a wide range of toppings, including more caramel, chocolate, or even cheese. Their unique shape protects the kernels from breaking and produces perfectly-ridged, crispy popcorn.

Wabash Valley Farms’ popcorn kernels are also ideal for those concerned about their health, as their products are locally grown with no added chemicals or preservatives. Additionally, they’re very low-calorie, making an excellent snack for those on a diet.


Mushroom popcorn is giving the old butterfly popcorn a run for its money. This larger and more substantial popcorn delivers maximum flavor and wont turn into a soggy mess when you throw on some hot butter. If you love popcorn then give yourself the ultimate treat with these highly rated and delicious mushroom popcorn choices.

Similar Posts